Even now when I see you
I start to relieve you
Don't know how
I could ever begin to forgive you

I never thought about it
I learned to live without it
But nothing seems to feel the same
If I should try again, and you should lie again
Don't know if I could stand the pain

Do I dare
Let you in once again and surrender?
Should I care?
Should I trust when my heart still remembers
How you lied, how I cried?
Now I see you want to make it, try
So I ask, won't you hear my prayer?
Do I love? Do I trust? Do I dare?

Oh yeah
Tell me, why did you play such a game that September?
Pretty lies
Were you real?
Were you just a pretender?

When I ain't back again
Saying that that was then
How are you gonna change your way?
I don't know what to do
'Cause I am still feeling you
But will the story end the same?

Do I dare? (Do I dare?)
Let you in once again and surrender
Let you back in my life?
Should I care?
Should I trust when my heart still remembers?
And it cuts like a knife
How you lied, how I cried
Now I say you want to make it, try
So I ask, won't you hear my prayer?
Do I love? Do I trust? Do I dare?

Oh yeah
I never thought about it
I learned to live without it
But, now, sometimes I feel just like I am gonna die without it
I don't know what to do
'Cause I am still feeling you
And I am still afraid that you'd break my heart in two

Don't know if I could stand the pain
But will the story end the same?
Do I dare? Do I trust? Do I dare?
Let you in once again and surrender?

Should I care? (Should I care?)
Should I trust when my heart still remembers?
When my heart still remember?
How you lied, how I cried (how I cried)
Now I say you want to make it, try
So I ask, won't you hear my prayer?
Do I love? Do I trust? Do I dare?

I never thought about it
I learned to live without it
But, now, sometimes I feel just like I am gonna die without it
I don't know what to do
'Cause I am still feeling you
I am still afraid that you'd break my heart in two

Do I dare? (How you lied, how I cried)
Let you in once again and surrender
Should I care? (I ask you to hear my prayer)
Should I trust when my heart still remembers?
(Do I dare) Do I dare
Let you in once again and surrender?

Copyright: Universal Music Publishing Group
Writer(s): Carl Allen Sturken, Evan A. Rogers