McDaid left the lineup in 1992, and was replaced by bassist David Hughes; by the time the Trash Can Sinatras' sophomore effort, I've Seen Everything, finally appeared in 1993, however, the ascendance of grunge essentially derailed whatever commercial momentum the group still had left, and 1996's A Happy Pocket was not even released in America. A new single, "Snow," followed in late 1999. They made a triumphant return to the scene in 2004 with their spinART release Weightlifting and a world tour that had them wowing old fans and gaining new ones with their typically wonderful display of melody and emotion. The group followed up the next year with Fez, a limited-edition album made up of live acoustic recordings recorded at New York's Fez nightclub.
After a relatively uneventful couple of years, the band reconvened in late 2007 to begin recording a new album. The results (which featured Carly Simon singing backing vocals on a song) were issued as In the Music by Lo-Five in the summer of 2009. The Trash Can Sinatras kept busy with a live album in 2009, Brel, and preparing a box set intended to feature their Fontana albums plus Weightlifting and bonus tracks. Unfortunately, it never saw the light of day, and the band resumed touring in 2010, playing their initial show in a fan's living room in Portland. In 2014, the band returned to the recording studio to work on their sixth album with producer Mike Mogis and on "sonic scenery," their old friend Simon Dine. Funded by a successful PledgeMusic campaign, Wild Pendulum was released in May of 2016 and the band headed out soon afterward on a tour of the U.S. ~ Jason Ankeny & Tim Sendra, Rovi